Home > Places > Cook Your Catch Restaurants in Naples

Cook Your Catch Restaurants in Naples

The beautiful waters of Naples, Florida attract visitors from across the globe and it’s no surprise why. There’s no limit to the number of fun activities that you enjoy.

fresh caught grouper in a cooler

When you’re here in Naples, you’re going to want to be spending time on the beach, on a boat, or just outside in general. After all, the bounty of the sea is what really draws people to this gem of a city and it’s what makes eating here unlike anywhere else. 

There are countless restaurants in Naples that serve up amazingly fresh fish right off the boat, but what if you want to eat the fish that you caught that day in a restaurant? Well, they have an answer for that!

That’s right! If you’ve been out fishing and had a lucky day, there are several restaurants around town that would be happy to fillet and cook your fish for you. Seafood doesn’t get any fresher than that!

perfectly cooked grouper fillets

There’s no better feeling than handing off your hard-earned catch to the staff and having it come back as a deliciously prepared meal. It’s a great experience, so go ahead and cast a few lines out and bring your fish to these establishments around town!

Naples Cook Your Catch Restaurants

  1. Kelly’s Fish House Dining Room
  2. The Dock at Crayton Cove
  3. The Bay House
  4. Riverwalk at Tin City
  5. Capri Fish House
  6. Pinchers Crab Shack

Kelly’s Fish House Dining Room

1302 5th Ave S, Naples, FL 34102
Phone: (239) 774-0494
Visit Website

The first place up is Kelly’s Fish House Dining Room and Naples locals will know all about this place already. Kelly’s is a staple of Naples and you need to check it out when you visit. 

You can find Kelly’s off of 5th Avenue, right across the channel from the Tin City Waterfront Shops. This restaurant has a gorgeous view of the water to enjoy while you dine on your own catch. 

Pull up and dock your boat when you’re feeling hungry the next time you’re in the area and have had some luck out on the water. 

The Dock at Crayton Cove

845 12th Ave S, Naples, FL 34102
Phone: (239) 263-9940
Visit Website

Next up is The Dock at Crayton Cove. This is another hotspot that you can’t come to Naples without visiting at least once. 

The best part about The Dock is that there are plenty of nearby charters in the area that will help put you on a trophy fish for you to take home. When you get back to the docks, just head on down to The Dock at Crayton Cove and the chefs there will take care of it. 

Check out The Dock off of 12th Avenue South near the Naples Depot Museum inside the Tin City shopping mall. You won’t regret it! 

The Bay House

799 Walkerbilt Rd, Naples, FL 34110
Phone: (239) 591-3837
Visit Website

The next cook your catch restaurant in Naples I want to recommend is The Bay House. This place is stunning from the indoor decor to the picturesque view of the water right from your table. 

The Bay House is located off of Walkerbilt Road, tucked away into the mangrove forests, overlooking the back bays of Naples. This place is perfect for an unforgettable dining experience made even better when you bring your own fresh-caught fish. 

Be sure to stop by The Bay House when you’re in the area, especially after a long day on the water of filling up the cooler with fish. 

Riverwalk at Tin City

1200 5th Ave S, Naples, FL 34102
Phone: (239) 263-2734
Visit Website

As if you needed any more reasons to visit the fantastic Tin City shopping mall in Naples, here’s another one. Riverwalk is a phenomenal place to eat, especially if you’re looking for someone to cook your catch. 

Your hard-earned fish will be in good hands when you bring it to Riverwalk. The chefs know exactly what to do to make it taste amazing, exactly the way you want it. 

I highly recommend timing your visit to Riverwalk to coincide with snook season down here in Florida. Snook are prized saltwater game fish and absolutely delightful to eat if you get the chance. 

Capri Fish House

203 Capri Blvd, Naples, FL 34113
Phone: (239) 389-5555
Visit Website

Capri Fish House is another place I want to mention because they never disappoint when I bring them my fish. I’ve presented them with snapper, grouper, even flounder, and they always prepare it perfectly. 

This lovely restaurant is located right on the water off of Capri Boulevard, not far from Marco Island. It’s tucked away among all of the local charters and fishing guides, so there’s no shortage of people willing to help you in your search for big fish. 

Definitely check out Capri Fish House for a good time, some cold drinks, and a fantastic place to have your catch of the day cooked for you. 

Pinchers Crab Chack

1200 5th Ave S, Naples, FL 34102
Phone: (239) 263-2734
Visit Website

Pinchers Crab Shack is a name that’s known all over the country, and for good reason. Not only do they have all the crab and other shellfish you could possibly want, but they’ll cook your catch right up for you, any way you like. 

When you’re coming off the boat and your cooler is full of fresh fish, just look for the Pinchers Crab Shack sign and you’ll be all set. Just pass of your fish, sit back with a drink, and wait for it to come back to you on a plate. 

Pinchers can be found in Tin City off of 5th Street in Naples, but there are plenty of other locations as well, so check them out!

Final Thoughts

A long day of fishing and relaxing on a boat can sure take it out of you. Luckily, when you’re too tired from a long day’s work, you can just hand off your freshly caught fish to the skilled chefs at these restaurants who will serve it up just the way you like without you having to lift a finger. 

You need to catch the fish before these places can cook it for you, so be sure to read up on all you need to know about fishing in Naples to ensure success on your trip!

Add comment