Fishmasters.com
Home > Fishing Charters and Guides > Top 13 Fishing Charters in Long Island

Top 13 Fishing Charters in Long Island

fishing rod in a saltwater motor boat during fishery day in blue ocean

Are you an avid fisherman looking for a new challenge? Or maybe you’re just getting started and looking for some guidance? Either way, fishing charters are the perfect solution.

fishing rod in a saltwater motor boat during fishery day in blue ocean

Charters can take you to some of the best fishing spots on Long Island, and give you access to experienced guides who can teach you everything you need to know.

Whether you’re targeting bass, flounder, or striped bass, there’s a charter that can help. So what are you waiting for? Start planning your next fishing trip today!


Island Girl Adventures Inc

Phone: 631-655-7988
Visit Website

people on a sunset cruises for an evening exploring the waters

Island Girl Adventures is a premier charter company operating out of Montauk NY.

With a combined 50 years of experience in fishing and boat handling you can be assured that Captains Bill and Maggie will provide you and your family/crew with an unforgettable and safe adventure on the breathtaking waters surrounding Montauk NY.

Specializing in inshore and near shore Montauk fishing charters for all levels of fishing enthusiasts.

If fishing isn’t your thing, let them take you on one of their Montauk sunset cruises for an evening to explore the waters and coastline surrounding the famous Montauk Lighthouse and one of the most beautiful sunsets you will ever experience.

This trip is truly one not to miss nor will it be soon forgotten. Your adventures await on the Island Girl


Blue Fin IV Inc.

Phone: 631-680-4800
Visit Website

two anglers fishing in deep ocean are holding a fish they caught

Captain Michael Potts has been fishing his entire life. During the sixties, his mother would take him along to ride shotgun in her airplane while she spotted swordfish for Michael’s father George and Uncle John on their third boat, the Blue Fin.

The Blue Fin was custom built for the Potts brothers in 1954 in Maine. They had been operating a charter boat as partners since 1944.

By the time Michael was 10 years old, he had steady work on the Blue Fin and other boats, and in those days sold much fish off the dock to customers who wanted fresh fish for dinner.

The family bought a 41′ boat that was custom built in Greenport, LI, for charter fishing in Montauk. It was engineered for the waters off Montauk with an impressive super stable hull design for comfort and a big cockpit.

Michael ran the Blue Fin IV as one of the top charter boats in Montauk from the perspective of putting fish on the dock, the number of trips he sails, and most importantly the great relationship that he has with his clients.


Sea Rogue Fishing Charters

Phone: 516-551-2177
Visit Website

Sea Rogue Fishing Charters, Sailing from Freeport, Long Island, New York provides private fishing adventures for smaller groups of three to four anglers.

They’ll personalize a trip that’s right for you…whether you’re a hard-core fisherman who wants to run offshore, or you want to relax with the family and catch fish in the bay. Fishing is meant to be fun and they know you will have a great time.

Long Island’s south shore near Jones Inlet boasts some of the finest saltwater fishing anywhere, and Sea Rogue Fishing Charters will make sure you take full advantage of all the great angling possibilities these waters offer.

Located only a short boat ride away, the bays, ocean, and local wrecks and reefs are home to numerous types of fish such as Striped Bass, Fluke, Sea Bass, Blackfish, Porgies, Bluefish, Cod, and more. They target all species in season.


Captain Fish Port Jefferson

Phone: 631-974-4933
Visit Website

Captain Fish of Port Jefferson is a LONG ISLAND FISHING CHARTER BOAT for hire business. They are hired by novice and experienced fisherman alike to catch lots of fish and to do it consistently and proficiently.

Family, friends, and children are all welcome aboard. They are licensed and insured fishing vessel that is commanded by a USCG Captain. Your captain is an experienced and knowledgeable fisherman that will be determined to put you on the fish.

Fishing has a science behind it and your captain will enjoy explaining and instructing you on the fundamentals of fishing. Consistent catches, great service, good times, guaranteed! Great LONG ISLAND FISHING!


Long Island Fishing Charters

Phone: 516-978-1634
Visit Website

four fishermen on a fishing charter boat

Capt Andy has over 30 years of regional fishing experience and is an accomplished writer, seminar speaker, tournament angler, and expert on both inshore and offshore fishing. He has been a licensed NY fishing charter captain for over 20 years.

Guests (of any age) need no prior fishing or boating experience, Capt Andy will provide all the instruction you need. He is also available for personalized instruction for anglers learning to fish the Long Island waters on their own boats.

Capt Andy is also comfortable working with kids and families and is the perfect choice for your child’s first charter fishing experience! Always be sure to let him know the ages of any children in the group to ensure the proper safety equipment is aboard and the trip plan is appropriate.


Codfather Fishing Charters

Phone: 516-868-9073
Visit Website

If you’re looking for a fishing charter, one of the best NY Fishing Charters on Long Island NY, then you should give ‘Mikey’ a call. The Codfather is Based out of Freeport Long Island New York off of the Nautical Mile (Woodcleft Ave).

On the scenic South Shore of LI, you can fish and also enjoy the Shops, Seafood Restaurants, Gambling Ships, Fishmongers & Boating around the Freeport – Merrick & Point Lookout areas.

They fish & catch fish YEAR-ROUND going after the BITE. Break your cabin fever with Winter Tog, Herring & Early Season Flounder to the Spring runs of Mackeral with the Blues and Stripers chasing them north to Summer Fluke, Weakfish, Sharks & Canyon trips to LI’s incredible Fall run of Striped Bass gorged on baitfish heading south…


Northport Fishing Charters

Phone: 631-707-3266
Visit Website

Come create an exciting new memory that lasts a lifetime aboard the ‘Sashimi.’ They offer fishing charters on beautiful Long Island Sound, sailing out of historic Northport harbor.

Northport Fishing Charters caters to custom fishing adventures. “Long Island Striped Bass fishing & Fluke fishing at it’s best!” They fish for most species in season. Also, they can accommodate small groups for clients, birthdays, sunset cruises, and family outings.


Hooks and Brooks Guide Service and Long Island Surf Fishing Charters

Phone: 631-589-0065
Visit Website

man on the fishing boat holds a fish

Hooks and Brooks Guide Service offers a variety of fly fishing and light tackle trips. Long Island Surf Fishing Charters offers outstanding guided surf fishing trips on Long Island’s South Shore, Montauk, North Shore, Back Bays, and Inlets.

Whether you are a novice looking for instruction or a seasoned angler looking for a challenge, they will design an exciting custom fishing adventure specifically for you!

Offering personalized and professional services to his clients, Mark Malenovsky can assist with all the plans for your trip, including lodging. He can provide top-notch rods, reels, and tackle if required, or if you prefer, you may bring and use your own equipment.


Captain Lou Fleet

Phone: 516-623-5823
Visit Website

Captain Lou Fleet has been the top name in the fishing and the party charter boat business since 1956. They also have their private parties and fun cruises.

They are conveniently located in Central Nassau County and are just a half-hour or less from New York City and eastern Long Island on the famous Nautical Mile. They specialize in half-day fluke fishing trips in the Summer, Private Fishing Charters.

Capt Lou’s Party Boats specializes in all Occasion Parties and Party Boat Rentals not limited to; Birthdays, Fundraisers, Churches, Sweet Sixteens, and more! Capt Lou’s Party Boat has many public cruises as well!

They also have the Sapphire Princess Yacht, which is part of our fleet specializing in Dinner Cruise Private Parties, and Weddings.


Celtic Quest Fishing Party/Charter Boat

Phone: 631-928-3926
Visit Website

Great Family Fishing Trips Sailing Daily. All Experience Levels are Welcome! Come spend a relaxing day on the water fishing on scenic Long Island Sound with your family and friends.

They provide you with all the fishing rods, bait and tackle you need as well as fishing instruction at no additional cost. Super fun atmosphere and very kid-friendly.

Fishing for all fish in season including Striped Bass, Porgies, Sea Bass, Blackfish, and more! Take a break from your busy life and come have some fun with them on the water!


Super Hawk

Phone: 516-607-3004
Visit Website

Long Island Fishing Boat lead by Captain Steve Kearney hosts some of the best fishing on Long Island. The Super Hawk sails daily out of Point Lookout Marina located at Point Lookout, exit M10, Loop Parkway, off the Meadowbrook Parkway.

The Super Hawk features two levels that can accommodate 130 passengers comfortably. The party fishing cruise vessel is designed with a spacious upper deck dance floor and a fully enclosed dining area down below for fishing groups and live party entertainment.


ANGLER Fishing Fleet

Phone: 718-659-8181
Visit Website

The Angler Fleet is a family-friendly business located in Port Washington, New York. They specialize in private charters and open boat fishing including their most popular half-day fishing trips, kids summer camp, and summer fireworks cruises (fireworks cruises suspended for 2020).

Join them on the calm, sheltered waters of Long Island Sound for a memorable fishing trip to catch flounder, blackfish, striped bass, or scup (porgy). Their kind, courteous crew is available to assist all skill levels.


American Sportfishing Charters

Phone: 516-457-8715
Visit Website

two lucky guys caught fish on their fishing trip

Join Captain John Marino for a morning day or evening of fishing or just cruising the sheltered waters of the Western Long Island Sound.

Experience Long Island fishing at its best within minutes of the dock. For the last 32 years Capt. John has sharpened and honed his skills in the water he calls his backyard.

Come and see firsthand why western sound fishing is one of the best-kept secrets on Long Island. The western sound has some of the most protected waters on the island, they can always find a place to fish so their clients are always comfortable.


Long Island Fishing Charter FAQs

How much is a fishing charter in Long Island?

The average price in Long Island for a half-day fishing trip of about 4 hours is around $500, and the price of a full-day trip will run you about $1000. 

Of course, there are many factors that may play into the cost of your Long Island fishing experience like the number of anglers in your party, trip length, the type and size of the boat, as well as the fishing technique you’ll be using. 

What are the top species of fish to catch in Long Island?

Guides in Long Island target a number of popular fish species, so it all depends on where you want to fish and what you want to catch. 

Some Long Island fishing charters will take you to explore the inshore areas like bays and flats for smaller game fish such as redfish, trout, snook, and tarpon. 

On the other hand, you can book a deep sea fishing charter that will target larger game fish like marlin, grouper, mahi-mahi, red snapper, and maybe even swordfish. 

What’s the difference between deep sea, inshore, and offshore fishing in Long Island?

There are many different ways to experience fishing in Long Island. When it comes to fishing guides, you typically have three options: inshore, offshore, and deep sea fishing charters. 

Inshore fishing means you’ll be staying in relatively shallow waters, fishing back bays, grass flats or within a few miles of the beaches for popular sport fish species.  The method is usually casting lures or using live baits. 

Offshore fishing is basically the same as deep sea fishing where the charter boat will take you out to open water where it gets much deeper.  Depth could range from 100 feet up to a few thousand feet deep.  You will target fish species like tuna, mahi-mahi, marlin, snapper and grouper.  Typically the method of fishing is trolling, but sometimes you can deep drop bait onto reefs or shipwrecks.  

Can You Keep Your Catch?

Most of the time, yes! If you’re wondering about keeping the fish you catch on your charter, then don’t worry because you will almost always be allowed to take your fish home.

Usually, the charter crew will fillet your fish for you once you arrive back at the dock, so that you can simply take it home and cook it up any way you like.

Depending on the guide you book, they may even take you to a nearby restaurant that will cook your catch for you in a number of different ways, as well. 

Which fishing charters in Long Island are good for families?

If you’re planning a fishing trip in Long Island for the family, you should make sure that the charter caters to families, especially if you are bringing children along. 

Luckily, many captains and their crew will be happy to accommodate families with children, and lots of them take pleasure in teaching kids all about fishing. 


Final Thoughts

Looking for a great fishing charter? Look no further than Long Island! Their experienced captains will take you to the best spots and help you reel in the big one. So come on out and enjoy a day of fishing! You won’t regret it.

Rocco Smith

Add comment

%d bloggers like this: