The Top 30 Fishing Lakes in Pennsylvania Ranked

I grew up fishing here in Pennsylvania, chasing trout in cold mountain streams and bass in farm ponds since my dad first handed me a rod as a kid. Since then I have fished my way across the state, from quiet electric-only lakes to big reservoirs that hold walleye, muskie, and stripers, and I still turn up new water every season. I have fished a good number of the lakes on this list myself, but I did not want this to come down to just my own opinion.

So I leaned on local anglers and guides I trust, dug into state fisheries data, and asked our followers to share the spots they actually fish. What follows is the result: thirty Pennsylvania lakes worth your time, with everything from Lake Erie walleye and Raystown stripers to muskie water, big-bass lakes, and crappie honey holes. Whether you fish from a boat, a kayak, or right off the bank, you will find something here. These are my picks for the best fishing lakes in the Keystone State.

30. Lake Frederic

Lake Frederic is a quiet reservoir near Newberry in Dauphin County. Covering a modest area, it’s ideal for anglers targeting smallmouth and largemouth bass, channel catfish, and even occasional flathead catfish and carp. Some channel catfish reach up to 26 inches and 8 pounds according to recent reports. Shoreline and boat fishing are both easy, with fish often found around submerged structure and along weedy edges. Local anglers highlight smallmouth bass as the top species, backed by logs of good catches. Ideal seasons run spring through fall, and a Pennsylvania fishing license is required. Enjoy the calm, diverse angling options here.

29. Leaser Lake

Leaser Lake is a 117-acre reservoir in Lehigh County that was rehabilitated and refilled after past drawdowns, with habitat structure added to rebuild the fishery. It holds largemouth bass, muskellunge, crappie, bluegill, and catfish, and is stocked with trout. Results can be inconsistent, and many anglers do better from a boat than the bank, so set expectations accordingly. The lake has electric-motor and paddle access, launches, and shoreline trails in a quiet, wooded setting. Early morning and the cooler months tend to fish best, and the muskie and bass are there for anglers willing to put in the time. It is a low-key local option.

28. Lake Galena

Lake Galena, located in Bucks County, offers a peaceful spot for anglers looking to catch largemouth bass, yellow perch, and bluegill. This scenic lake has calm waters, perfect for fishing from the shore or a small boat. Surrounded by woods, it’s a great place to enjoy nature while trying your luck at a big catch. Whether you’re a seasoned angler or just looking to relax by the water, Lake Galena provides a quiet retreat. It’s an ideal spot for those who want to fish in a less crowded setting, with beautiful views adding to the overall experience.

27. Octoraro Lake

Octoraro Lake is a popular fishing spot in Pennsylvania, known for its peaceful surroundings and diverse fish population. It’s a great location for anglers looking to catch species like largemouth bass, bluegill, and white perch. The lake’s calm waters offer a perfect setting for a day on the water, whether you’re casting from a boat or fishing off the shore. Nearby, you’ll find scenic views and a quiet atmosphere, making it a good place to relax between catches. Whether you’re new to fishing or experienced, Octoraro Lake offers plenty of opportunities for a successful outing.

26. Harveys Lake

Harveys Lake in Luzerne County is the largest natural lake in Pennsylvania by volume, ringed by homes and a busy recreational scene. It holds largemouth and smallmouth bass, yellow perch, panfish, walleye, and stocked trout, with deep, clear water that fishes well for bass and perch. It is not a quiet lake on warm weekends, when boat and personal watercraft traffic picks up after mid-morning, so early starts and off-season trips are best for serious anglers. Drop-offs, the deeper basin, and shoreline structure hold fish. Spring and fall are prime for bass and walleye, and winter brings ice fishing for perch and panfish.

25. Mauch Chunk Lake

Mauch Chunk Lake, nestled in Jim Thorpe, Pennsylvania, offers a peaceful setting for anglers. The lake is home to a variety of fish, including largemouth bass, pickerel, and black crappie. Its clear waters and surrounding woodlands create a relaxing backdrop for a day of fishing. Whether you’re casting from the shore or out on a boat, you’ll find plenty of space to enjoy the calm. The area also features hiking trails, so after a successful fishing session, you can stretch your legs and take in the scenery. Mauch Chunk Lake is a great spot for those looking for a quiet fishing retreat.

24. Beltzville Lake

Beltzville Lake in Pennsylvania offers a great spot for anglers looking to cast a line. The lake is known for its diverse fish species, including largemouth bass, smallmouth bass, and striped bass. Whether you’re a beginner or experienced, the calm waters provide plenty of opportunities to fish from the shore or by boat. Nearby parks and picnic areas make it a perfect spot to spend the day. If you enjoy a peaceful setting with great fishing, Beltzville is a place you’ll want to check out. It’s not just about the catch; it’s about enjoying a day on the water in a relaxed atmosphere.

23. Colyer Lake

Colyer Lake in Centre County, Pennsylvania, is a quiet, 77-acre reservoir perfect for a fishing getaway. It offers excellent shoreline access and two boat launches for electric or unpowered boats. Anglers here often land largemouth bass, chain pickerel, bluegill, crappie, channel catfish, yellow perch, pumpkinseed, and bullhead. Early spring through fall brings strong bass action, while warm summer evenings are great for catfish. Crappie and bluegill peak in spring and fall. The dam area draws larger fish, and the eastern shoreline offers good shore casting. With trails, parking, and occasional port-a-potties near the launch, it’s a solid spot for day trips.

22. Shenango Lake

Shenango Lake in Mercer County covers about 3,560 acres with 56 miles of shoreline, making it one of the larger fisheries in the northwest. It is a hotspot for channel catfish, with crappie slabs in the 14 to 16 inch range and solid numbers of largemouth and smallmouth bass. Hybrid striped bass and walleye add variety, while northern pike and muskie occasionally surface. Early morning and late afternoon fish best, and Clark Recreation Area and several ramps provide access, with over 300 nearby campsites. Note that a PCB do-not-eat advisory covers the Shenango River below the dam, so check current consumption guidance before keeping fish.

21. Green Lane Reservoir

Green Lane Reservoir is a great spot for anglers in Pennsylvania. Located in Montgomery County, it’s known for its peaceful surroundings and clear waters. The reservoir is home to various fish species, including largemouth bass, smallmouth bass, catfish, and bluegill. Whether you’re casting from the shore or using a boat, the calm water makes for a relaxing experience. The park around the reservoir also offers a chance to enjoy nature with hiking trails and picnic areas. If you’re looking for a quiet, well-maintained fishing location, Green Lane Reservoir is a solid option that offers something for both experienced anglers and beginners.

20. Lake Redman

Lake Redman is a roughly 290-acre water-supply reservoir in York County, part of William H. Kain County Park alongside neighboring Lake Williams. It holds largemouth bass, bluegill, yellow perch, crappie, and channel catfish, and is stocked to support the fishery. Boats are limited to electric motors and paddled craft, and shoreline trails give bank anglers good access. The lake sees steady local pressure, so it fishes more as a numbers water than a trophy spot. Coves and the dam area hold bass and panfish, with spring and fall the most productive seasons. It is an easy, convenient option close to York.

19. Conneaut Lake

Conneaut Lake in Crawford County is the largest natural lake in Pennsylvania, a glacial lake covering roughly 929 acres in the northwest. It holds the state records for muskie and white bass, and the fishery also includes largemouth and smallmouth bass, northern pike, walleye, crappie, bluegill, and yellow perch. The commission stocks walleye and muskie, and the lake has a reputation for quality panfish and trophy bass. Shoreline access is limited by private homes and businesses, so it fishes best by boat, and unlimited-horsepower rules mean heavy recreational traffic on warm weekends. Bass and panfish lead through the warmer months, with walleye best early and late in the day.

18. Foster Joseph Sayers Lake

Foster Joseph Sayers Lake, located in central Pennsylvania, is a great spot for anglers looking to reel in some fish. This peaceful lake is stocked with a variety of species, including largemouth bass, black crappie, and white crappie, making it a popular destination for both beginners and seasoned fishermen. Whether you’re casting from the shore or in a boat, the lake offers plenty of opportunities to catch a big one. The surrounding area is perfect for a day out, with hiking trails and picnic areas that provide a relaxing atmosphere. It’s an ideal location to spend time outdoors or enjoy some quiet time alone. If you’re seeking a fishing experience that’s both enjoyable and rewarding, Foster Joseph Sayers Lake is definitely worth considering for your next outing.

17. Keystone Lake

Keystone Lake is an 850-acre reservoir near Plumville in Armstrong County, the largest lake in the county and a strong multi-species fishery. Deep water down to about 90 feet supports largemouth and smallmouth bass, walleye, muskellunge, yellow perch, crappie, bluegill, and stocked trout. The lake is known well enough for its muskie that guides run dedicated trips here. Shallows and wetlands at the northern end hold panfish and bass, while the deeper basin and points produce walleye and muskie. Boat launches provide access, and ice fishing is popular in winter. Spring and fall fish best for bass, walleye, and crappie.

16. Lake Marburg

Lake Marburg is a popular fishing spot located in Codorus State Park, known for its peaceful atmosphere and diverse fish species. Anglers can expect to reel in largemouth bass, perch, and bluegill, making it a go-to location for both beginners and experienced fishermen. The lake’s calm waters offer excellent conditions for a relaxing fishing day. Surrounding the lake are scenic views of woodlands and rolling hills, creating the perfect backdrop for a day out on the water. Whether you’re casting from a boat or the shore, Lake Marburg provides plenty of space to enjoy your time. The area also has picnic spots and walking trails, so it’s great for a day out. With its variety of fish and quiet environment, Lake Marburg is a must-visit for anyone looking to fish in Pennsylvania.

15. Ontelaunee Reservoir

Ontelaunee Reservoir, also called Lake Ontelaunee, is a roughly 1,000-acre City of Reading water-supply lake in Berks County. It holds strong numbers of crappie along with largemouth bass, bluegill, channel catfish, and yellow perch, and northern snakehead have also turned up here. The key thing to know is access: no boats of any kind are permitted, so this is a bank-fishing lake, and shoreline spots can be limited. Causeway areas and points near the dam are productive. Crappie fishing is the main draw in spring, with bass and catfish through the warmer months. It is a solid local pick for shore anglers willing to walk.

14. Marsh Creek Reservoir

Marsh Creek Reservoir is a great spot for fishing, located in Chester County, Pennsylvania. The calm waters are perfect for catching largemouth bass, bluegill, and perch. With a fishing pier and plenty of shoreline access, anglers can easily find a good spot to cast their line. The surrounding park is also a nice place for a day out, offering walking trails and picnic areas for those who want a break from fishing. Whether you’re a seasoned fisherman or just starting out, Marsh Creek offers a peaceful environment for everyone to enjoy. The variety of fish and quiet atmosphere make it a go-to location for a relaxing day on the water.

13. Cross Creek Lake

Cross Creek Lake is a 244-acre county-park impoundment near Avella in Washington County, and it consistently ranks among the best bass and panfish waters in the region. It is managed under Big Bass and panfish enhancement regulations, with one of the highest largemouth bass densities the state has recorded and a strong reputation for quality crappie and bluegill. Channel catfish, saugeye, and yellow perch are also present. Stained, fertile water and a network of coves give bass and crappie plenty of cover. A handicap-accessible dock and boat launches support access, and a Washington County launch permit is required. Spring and fall fish best.

12. Glendale Lake

Glendale Lake, located in the heart of Pennsylvania, offers a peaceful environment for fishing and outdoor activities. The lake is known for its clear waters, which are home to a variety of fish, including largemouth bass, bluegill, and sunfish. Anglers can enjoy casting their lines from the shore or a boat, with plenty of spots that provide easy access to the water. Along with fishing, the lake is surrounded by scenic areas perfect for hiking, picnicking, or just relaxing by the water. Wildlife is abundant, making it a great place for nature lovers to spot birds and other animals. Whether you’re an experienced fisherman or just looking for a quiet spot to unwind, Glendale Lake provides a perfect setting to enjoy some time outdoors.

11. Youghiogheny River Lake

Youghiogheny River Lake is a 2,800-acre flood-control reservoir on the southwestern border, running about 16 miles into Maryland. It is a strong multi-species fishery with a naturally reproducing walleye population, along with smallmouth and largemouth bass, crappie, northern pike, muskellunge, yellow perch, and catfish. Local clubs run tournaments here, and smallmouth grow big in the rocky water. Levels fluctuate with flood-control operation, so check conditions before launching, with ramps and a marina available when the pool is up. Walleye lead in spring and early summer, smallmouth fish well through the warmer months, and crappie stack around cover in spring and fall.

10. Lake Wilhelm

Lake Wilhelm is a 1,680-acre warmwater reservoir in Maurice K. Goddard State Park, Mercer County. It is one of the better multi-species lakes in western Pennsylvania, managed as a muskellunge brood-stock water and stocked with walleye and channel catfish. Anglers also find largemouth and smallmouth bass, crappie, bluegill, yellow perch, and northern pike. A marina, several launches, and accessible piers support boat and bank fishing, with a 20-horsepower limit on motors. Coves and the dam area hold bass and panfish, while walleye and muskie roam the main lake. Ice fishing accounts for many of the larger fish caught here each winter.

9. Allegheny Reservoir (PA)

Allegheny Reservoir, also called Kinzua, stretches across Warren County and into New York within the Allegheny National Forest, covering about 12,000 acres of deep, forested water. It is a genuine multi-species destination, holding walleye, smallmouth bass, muskellunge, northern pike, yellow perch, crappie, and even lake trout in the deeper basins. The fishing can run feast or famine given the size and depth, so electronics and covering water help. Remote shoreline, boat launches, and campgrounds make it well suited to multi-day trips. Smallmouth and walleye lead spring through fall, while perch and walleye draw ice anglers in winter when conditions allow.

8. Pinchot Lake

Pinchot Lake is a 340‑acre warmwater reservoir in Gifford Pinchot State Park, York County. Known as a “Big Bass Lake,” it’s specially managed with size and creel limits for bass. You’ll fish for largemouth and smallmouth bass, muskellunge, hybrid striped bass, walleye, channel catfish, crappie, sunfish, and even carp. Three boat ramps support electric or unpowered vessels, with ADA-accessible fishing pads and a pier. Ideal spots include weedy coves, inlet areas, and near the dam. Best action usually comes in early morning and evening during spring through fall. In winter, the lake also welcomes ice fishing if conditions allow.

7. Blue Marsh Lake

Blue Marsh Lake is a 1,150-acre Army Corps reservoir in Berks County, popular for both fishing and recreation. It produces quality largemouth and smallmouth bass, plus crappie, catfish, walleye, and panfish, and it has a reputation for big bass. The water runs stained rather than clear, and the lake sees heavy boat and personal watercraft traffic on warm weekends, so early mornings and weekdays fish best. Quiet coves and points hold bass, while the creek arms are good for crappie and catfish. Several launches and a long shoreline support boat and bank access. Spring through fall is the prime stretch.

6. Lake Wallenpaupack

Lake Wallenpaupack is one of Pennsylvania’s most popular spots for fishing, offering a great variety of fish and scenic views. The lake is known for its diverse range of fish species, including largemouth bass, smallmouth bass, and rock bass, making it a favorite for anglers of all skill levels. It’s a perfect location for both relaxed casting and more serious fishing. The surrounding area also offers a peaceful setting, with plenty of spots to set up and enjoy the quiet, whether from the shore or on a smaller boat. If you’re looking to spend a day fishing, the lake has a lot to offer, whether you’re a seasoned angler or just trying it out. Plus, the natural beauty of the area adds to the experience, making it a great spot for a day outdoors. Whether you’re fishing solo or with friends, the lake provides an inviting atmosphere to enjoy the sport.

5. Pymatuning Reservoir

Pymatuning Reservoir straddles the Pennsylvania and Ohio line in the northwest corner of the state and covers roughly 17,000 acres, making it one of the largest lakes in the region. It is a well-known walleye, crappie, and muskellunge fishery, with largemouth bass, channel catfish, and bullhead also common. The lake gets heavy fishing pressure and a reputation as a numbers water rather than a trophy water, but it still produces steady action and the occasional big walleye or muskie. Boats are limited to 20 horsepower. Spring and fall are best for walleye and crappie, and ice fishing is popular in winter.

4. Lake Arthur

Lake Arthur in Pennsylvania offers a peaceful spot for fishing. The lake is known for its clean water and natural surroundings, making it a great place for anglers of all skill levels. The shoreline is dotted with trees and offers plenty of space to set up for a long day of fishing. You can expect to catch a variety of fish here, including largemouth bass, walleye, and panfish. It’s a spot where you can relax, enjoy the outdoors, and experience a quieter side of fishing. Whether you’re casting from the shore or using a boat, Lake Arthur provides a solid chance to reel in something big. Plus, the surrounding area is perfect for a post-fishing walk, adding to the overall peaceful vibe. If you’re looking for a spot to escape the rush of everyday life, this lake is well worth the visit.

3. Lake Nockamixon

Lake Nockamixon offers anglers a peaceful spot for a day on the water. Situated in Bucks County, this lake is known for its mix of species, including largemouth bass, smallmouth bass, catfish, and sunfish. Whether you’re casting from a boat or fishing from the shore, the area provides plenty of space to find the perfect spot. The lake is a popular choice for those looking to escape the hustle and bustle, offering a relaxing atmosphere that makes it easy to focus on fishing. The surrounding park also adds to the experience with its walking trails and picnic areas, making it a great spot to spend time outdoors. Whether you’re a seasoned angler or just getting started, Lake Nockamixon’s easy access and peaceful setting make it a solid choice for a fishing trip.

2. Raystown Lake

Raystown Lake in Huntingdon County is the largest lake located entirely within Pennsylvania, covering about 8,300 acres of deep, clear water. It is best known for striped bass, which run large and draw anglers from across the region, along with a strong lake trout fishery that is unusual for the state. Smallmouth bass, largemouth bass, crappie, and catfish round out the options. The deep main lake rewards trolling and electronics, while coves and points hold bass and panfish. Multiple launches, marinas, and miles of shoreline support boat and bank fishing. Spring through fall is prime, and the lake fishes year-round.

#1 – Lake Erie

Lake Erie, the shallowest and warmest of the Great Lakes, offers some of the best freshwater fishing in North America. Pennsylvania’s 50-mile stretch of shoreline near Erie, PA, is packed with access points, piers, and boat launches. The lake is famous for walleye, with peak action from late spring through fall. You’ll also find smallmouth bass, yellow perch, steelhead, and lake trout. Anglers fish by boat, from shore, or in tributary streams like Elk Creek and Walnut Creek during steelhead runs in fall and spring. Summer trolling is popular for walleye, while bass thrive along rocky points and shoals. It’s a year-round fishery with huge variety.

More about Fishing Lakes in Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania offers some of the best fishing opportunities in the country, with its abundance of lakes and diverse fish species. Whether you’re a seasoned angler or just starting, the state’s lakes provide everything from peaceful, quiet spots to popular fishing destinations. You’ll find a variety of fish, including bass, trout, walleye, and catfish, making it a perfect place for all types of fishing. With many lakes offering year-round access and beautiful landscapes, Pennsylvania is a top choice for anyone looking to cast a line and enjoy the outdoors. Get ready to reel in your next catch in this fishing paradise.

🎣 Pennsylvania Fishing Lakes: Quick FAQ

1. What types of fish can I catch in Pennsylvania lakes?
   Pennsylvania’s lakes are home to a variety of fish species, including largemouth and smallmouth bass, walleye, trout, crappie, bluegill, yellow perch, muskellunge, northern pike, and catfish.
2. Do I need a fishing license?
   Yes, anglers aged 16 and over must have a valid Pennsylvania fishing license.
3. Are there any free fishing days?
   Yes, Pennsylvania offers two Fish-for-Free Days each year, where anglers can fish without a license. These days are typically in May and July.
4. Can I fish year-round?
   Yes, many lakes in Pennsylvania offer year-round fishing opportunities. However, specific regulations regarding seasons, size, and possession limits vary by species and location, so it’s important to check before you head out.
5. Are there any special regulations for certain lakes?
   Yes, some lakes have unique rules. For instance, certain areas have restrictions on fishing gear or require anglers to follow stricter catch-and-release policies. Always check the latest regulations for the specific lake you plan to visit.
6. Where can I get more information?
   For detailed maps, lake-specific regulations, and fishing reports, check out the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission’s official website.